“Mama, am I pretty?” tearing her eyes away from the reflection of herself, the mother stared into the wide eyes of her daughter. The little girl bore a wide smile, showing off her missing front teeth, black hair which had been tied up moments ago now rested on her shoulders. She was adorable, with little cheeks that strangers and relatives alike liked to squeeze and skin that shined whiter than snow. The mother was filled with pride, not only had her son been handsome, but her two daughters were beautiful. Perfect little dolls that served as a trophy to boast about around their leering relatives.
“The prettiest, anak” the mother said.
“Mama, am I pretty?” the 12-year-old girl asked in tears. Gone was the snow-white skin, but instead replaced with a warm tan caused by too many hours in the sun with her friends. Her missing teeth, now replaced with much bigger ones that took up most of her mouth. The little cheeks were filled to the brim with fat. Along with her stomach and thighs which seemed to jiggle too much when she walked. The mother had noticed the change, and she knew the relatives had started to talk.
The girl had noticed it too. The adoration she felt growing up as a toddler had completely vanished. The harsh feeling of judgment crawled up her spine the moment she met eyes with anyone in that wretched family. It was pitiful really, the shining star had fallen from grace. She went from the ideal swan to the ugly duckling the second she strayed from their definition of beauty.
As she stared at herself in the mirror, the ugly duckling started to wonder why she had let herself go this much. God had been generous enough to bless her with natural beauty, yet she let the gift go to waste.
“Beauty is everything, my dear, without it you’re nothing.” The words her lola had whispered to her as an impressionable child echoed through her mind.
I am nothing. I am nothing. I am nothing.
What had been a meaningless comment by her lola had begun to root itself deep within her very being. At first, it was a meer seed planted into infertile soil, and it remained that way until she reached the tender of 12.
Her older sister had just started high school, she had long shed the chubby cheeks, stubby legs, and the minuscule amount of baby fat she had in the first place. Instead, it was replaced with a sharp jawline, long slim legs, and a slender build. The relatives were enthralled by the older sister’s beauty, praising the mother on a job well done.
The little girl, of course, did not mind the praise directed towards her sister, she was in fact very beautiful. She was actually very proud of having a sister that pretty and viewed her as a role model. She didn’t mind when the titas called her the lesser version of her sister. She didn’t mind the backhanded compliments thrown at her under the scrutiny of many eyes. She didn’t mind it when they told her she would be prettier if she lost weight. If her skin was lighter. If she didn’t eat so much. Except, she did mind.
The seed planted years prior by the words of her lola had grown to its full size, entrapping her in a void of self-degradation and shame. It chipped away at the wall she had built around herself the second the harsh words were spewed at her. The ugly duckling had grown up coddled by her immediate family, only to be subjected to the harsh reality forced on her by her extended family. In their eyes, she was less than perfect, imperfect to be exact, and that was the greatest sin a girl could ever commit.
Tearing her eyes away from the reflection of herself she made eye contact with her mother standing in the doorway of her room. The mother could only smile in pity as she stared at the tears running down the face of her daughter.
“Anak, come eat dinner is ready,” the mother said before she closed the door.
The girl looked down at the fat of her stomach stretching the material of her shirt, “but I don’t wanna eat” she whispered to herself.
That night an ugly duckling could be seen solemnly finishing her plate of food surrounded by swans.
2 months had passed and the girl had long forgotten the pain caused by the words thrown at her. Most likely caused by the lack of contact with her extended family, courtesy of her mother, although she hadn’t admitted to it. Even though the mother never verbally stated it, she could tell she was regretful and angry at the hurtful comments made by her family. The young girl had long forgotten it though and cheerfully continued to be herself, and for that the other was grateful. She silently prayed that nothing would knock off the smile on the little girl's face as she watched her happily munch on the hashbrowns she made. Not sensing the incoming calamity that would destroy the girl’s defenses.
That calamity came in the form of her father. The father loved his daughter dearly but did not possess the same gentleness and kindness his wife had. Often brash and inconsiderate, he spoke his mind with a rough voice. The man had just picked up his two daughters from school, his oldest son had long graduated and had gone off to college. Upon their arrival home, he
watched as his youngest daughter ran to the freezer to cook up her favorite hashbrowns. Slightly disgusted by the appetite the girl possessed at a young age the father could only watch as she placed 5 hashbrowns in the oven.
“Are you sharing the others with your sister?” he asked. “No, I’m just hungry.”
“You know, maybe if you didn’t eat that much you would look more like your sister and less like a pig,” the father said in his loud voice.
Freezing at the words uttered by her own father, the girl could feel the walls she had built up completely shattered. She could take insults or backhanded compliments uttered by jeering titas, titos, and cousins, but nothing prepared her for the man's comments.
Quietly, the heartbroken girl turned off the oven and walked up the stairs closing the door, as well as herself from the outside world. She stood in the same spot she stood 2 months prior.
“You really are nothing” she whispered to herself as the first tear of the night rolled down her face.
As days passed, the family noticed a change in the young girl. She constantly begged the mother to sign her up for sports, something she had no interest in before. She avoided the sun like a vampire, only going outside when deemed necessary. Most noticeably she locked herself in her room and away from the noise of her family, and most importantly away from the onslaught of rude comments spewed at her by her father. All of which never reached the ears of her mother. The dad thought nothing of the words he spewed and deemed them nothing, while the daughter acknowledged the man’s ignorance and didn’t want to try anymore.
Years passed and the girl was in high school, much like her sister had been before. She walked around the halls with anxiety brewing in the pit of her stomach. The girl so wounded by the judgemental stares of her family could not walk in public without thinking people were judging her. She could not meet new people without assuming they either hated her or thought she was ugly.
The girl, worn out by her day at school hurried home with hasty steps. Upon her arrival, she walked up the stairs to the entrance of her room and stood in front of her mirror. Hearing a noise to the left of her, the girl looked away from her reflection in the mirror and made eye contact with her mother.
“Mama, am I pretty?”
The mother looked at her youngest daughter. She was beautiful, the chubby cheeks had disappeared and was replaced with a delicate jaw and slim face. The protruding fat that had
once stuck out was nowhere to be seen and was instead replaced with a toned abdomen. The result of the endless sports her daughter subjected herself to. Her chipmunk teeth, nicely straightened out by braces, and her light skin shining bright.
The mother felt herself tear up, such a beautiful girl had been exposed to the toxic beauty standards created by society but enforced by those closest to her. The girl had successfully bloomed into a beautiful swan but threw away her own confidence and happiness she had when she was younger. All in pursuit of the subjective topic of beauty. Not once in her life had the girl been ugly, she was just made to believe those lies as an impressionable young girl. The daughter stood there looking desperately at her mother, waiting for the reply she had heard countless times before. The girl was beautiful, but she was broken, and only one thing would appease her.
The mother smiled solemnly, “the prettiest,” she whispered.
I really loved the message in your piece. There are so many young girls (and guys) who have such a negative perception of themselves due to the comments of their family members. I know from experience how much those comments can hurt, even if the one commenting didn't think much of what they had said. Overall, I think you did a really great job :)
ReplyDelete- Diana Quintanilla
I love this story alot. Although it is a story, it speaks about the truths in not only society's beauty standards, but also how your own family members expect you to look sometimes. I like how you indicate in the end that the girl becomes "beautiful" yet only on the surface, knowing she is actually broken. - Mary Ojo
ReplyDeleteThis has to be one of the most beautifully written and impactful short stories I have ever read. My heart goes out to the main character; her pain and her perceived diminishing self-worth was so painful to read, it genuinely stung. The message was even stronger. I wish every person in the world could read this, since the issue is so universal. So many could empathize with the main character and it directly calls out the detrimental societal standards of beauty. Thank you for writing such a wonderful piece, you did a spectacular job. - Sumbal Sharif
ReplyDeleteCaitlin, I almost cried.
ReplyDeleteI truly read this in awe as I examined the growth of the beautiful swan-like girl who believed she was an ugly duckling. I hope and believe this girl believes her mother, and will strive to heal herself without succumbing to the beauty standards that society witholds.
- Deisha Son
I really enjoyed the repetition of the question, “Mama, am I pretty?” because it demonstrated and proves that change is inevitable and comes with time, yet our insecurities prevail. The continuous repetition shows the lingering pain and thought given to the girl’s issues in a powerful, but structured presentation, which I especially like because it evokes the controlling affect it has over her. Repeating, “she didn’t mind” shows the grand accumulation of negativity that, in the end, becomes intolerable and reveals the truth that “she did mind.” Forced change that is done to fit in/satisfy and not necessarily to be happy was shown to come with costs and elucidates the importance of loving yourself above anything else. I really enjoyed the ending and how the mother’s reaction was a parallel to the daughter’s condition and self-outlook. Thank you! :)
ReplyDelete- Paola Rodriguez
I absolutely loved how this story spoke volumes about the damage societal views can have on the younger generation, such as loss of confidence, while simultaneously revealing that "beauty" is not defined by your size or any other trivial standard. -Saffiya H
ReplyDeleteThis was a very moving piece I think almost everyone can relate to in some way. Every family party I go to, there is always one tita (aunt) or lola who has to make a remark on my weight. As much as outer-beauty is not as important as inner-beauty, there is no question people, are pressured to look some type of way to fit the part in someone's eyes, which in general terms, just really sucks. I admired the allusions to the Ugly Duckling story, and the sentence, "Mama, am I pretty?," because it reminded of a song back in the old 50s, which just goes to show how far the value of "beauty" holds in society. The power of validation is strongly exemplified in your written piece as well. Humans crave for validation, most importantly from the people we love. You did an outstanding job on this.
ReplyDelete- Chloe Baronia
The way you structured and exemplified this piece was beautfiul. Beauty standards these days have changed significanly and it has became a major issue. You wrote a piece that gave the allusiosn of beauty standards but also the strength that a girl or women holds by overcoming the stereotype. - Valerie Rivera
ReplyDeleteThis story spoke volumes about current beauty standards in society. You portrayed it effortlessly by comparing the way she felt as an ugly duckling to the way she felt as a swan. I especially loved the way you held the mother's love and appreciation of the daughter regardless of her size constant in the story as it goes on to show that even the most important people can't keep you from falling flat - Edana Avila
ReplyDeleteThis is a really beautiful piece that truly encapsulates how society is damaging to young girls. Your repetition of certain phrases and inclusion of the girl's transformation in her young-adulthood all drive home how much she felt pressured to change. Your message about being made to fit into a particular mould at a young age is something that I know a lot of girls struggle with, and the point of view in this piece makes it relatable and easy to understand. This is by far one of the best short stories I've ever read, and you should be extremely proud of yourself :) Amazing job!
ReplyDelete-Aubrey Peterson
Not that this necessarily matters when reading this but I personally am Filipino like the family in this story and was incredibly shifted by the clear impact because I could picture myself and so many other young girls or people in general in her place. Hearing the quiet whispers or the constant comments and nags from everyone around whether it be from friends, family, anyone, it all truly just eventually turns into screams and torments, which genuinely is so unfortunate because of how usual the situation is to so many. While reading this, I was really thinking to myself "Wow, being raised in our society and in our world today is truly just a curse in the end." We are so focused on the approval of others because that's what we were all raised to seek. Hoping stories like this continue to be spread and written and spoken about because change needs to be made about how our future generations will live. Our children and their children do not deserve to live lives that are controlled by the unnecessary and harsh words from others. Caitlin.. I love it.
ReplyDeleteI really love the story especially given the fact that this is true to a lot of people. Many families go through this especially traditional ones. I go through it myself because people find a way to make you feel insecure. Overall, you piece was really enjoyable to read and one of the many stories that spoke the truth.
ReplyDelete-Keke Pandher
This piece really hit different. Even though I'm not a girl, I always felt insecure about my body, I felt like I had to look a certain way in order to get people to like me, and I still feel like that actually. Once those roots take in, it takes a lot of effort to pull out, and I'm still trying to do that. I honestly believe that the societal expectations we have mess with us and prevent us from expressing our true selves, telling us we have to act a certain way and be a certain way, and your piece really resonated with me and showed how dangerous this can be to a person. It was really well written, and it's honestly a heart-wrenching piece, which is an amazing feat on your part. You did a great job.
ReplyDelete-Ronneth Kennedy
This was super well written! I love how you incorporated the girl's inner dialogue and you connected it to the outside comments she received from her relatives. This is definitely a relevant topic in today's society, and you did a very good job at portraying the harsh reality of it (especially how it affects people at a very young age). Good job! - Angelique Maylad
ReplyDeleteThis was an amazing piece of writing. So many times throughout history we see this same story and it is so sad how many people are affected by this same thing constantly especially young women. In our world beauty is a box either you fit or you don't and there are many requirements to even be deemed "beautiful" or "worthy". Another broad and great point you touched on were generational curses and colorism these are big problems we see so much today even through all the progression we are trying to make as a generation but I believe over time we will start to become less vain and love ourselves and maybe not in a day, week or month but for those after us. Thank you for taking time to write this-Kasaia Gray
ReplyDeleteWow. This is such an important topic and I am so glad you addressed it so nicely. So many people have negative self views, sadly. This was beautifully written and I can not express this enough.
ReplyDeleteThis piece of writing is really well written and relatable. The details within the story really make you sit here and think and really portrays these thoughts well. Good job! :) -Hailee Cianciminio
ReplyDeleteThis writing was very heartfelt and held very deep meaning to it. A lot of people hold such high standards for themselves because of the people around them. I think it's there is much significance in feeling comfortable in your own skin. I really like how this writing brought awareness to that. To not feel the need to live up to societies standards. To be content with your physical appearance and overall who you are. 10/10. -Jacob M
ReplyDeleteThis was so well-written and beautifully demonstrates the society's destructive tendencies to tear people down with their unbelievable standards of beauty. Through your use of symbolism and story telling, the reader was able to understand this social stigma and also be exposed to the idea that confidence is key. -Marissa Rivera
ReplyDeleteThis piece was super well written and this can really show the inner conflicts of everyone, not just girls. However, it is easier to write about a girl's mindset about beauty and mental health because we hear about it the most
ReplyDelete-Gaby Velasquez
That was a really impactful essay! I can relate to it myself, because my parents have certain standards you should have as an Indian girl. I alway felt self-conscious when they point of my flaws.
ReplyDelete-Hrishika Reddy Nanamala
Caitlin! This blog was so well written! You really managed to capture how body shaming and societal standards, especially those impressed on you by your own family can impact and completely transform the way you see yourself. I loved the ending of the blog where the girl, forever changed by her parent's words, now craves validation at all times despite the fact that she's lost all her baby fat. Super good!- Somi Nebedum
ReplyDelete